Bandwagons and hockey
I don’t apologize for being a band wagoneer upon occasion. Bandwagons are fun! We should all be able to jump on them when so inspired. One has to hope that the wagon and streets are safe and the people on the wagon are compatible. Reckless bandwagon drivers may need to be removed.
Did you know that Wikipedia has a list of riots in history, and Vancouver is the most recent entry?
The riot was disappointing and disturbing, but the media are going overboard in the analysis and judgement of the onlookers. Wonderful and terrible things happen and our immediate responses can be stunningly different. I understand the urge to watch and photograph a train wreck. Mob mentality is a tricky subject, and something that civilization struggles to control. The fine line between a crowd and a mob was illustrated on Wednesday night. The problem is as Andrew Potter points out, that “Forget Freud, Forget Marx. Rioting, above all, is fun.” I certainly don’t condone the actions, but I am a little uncomfortable with the self righteous indignation and over-analysis.
Beauty and pride
Vancouver is my favourite city, but it has long bothered me to hear and see the jingoistic ads promoting tourism in British Columbia – “the best place on earth” we are told over and over again. “The most beautiful city in the world.” [I’ll stay away from the broader topic of Canadian chauvinism for today, and focus on the Stanley Cup 2011 riot.] The spontaneous messages written on plywood covering smashed windows are more touching.
Vancouver tops various international ratings for most liveable city in the world. I agree with those ratings, which is why I live in the area. Of course, the high cost of housing keeps me from living in the city of Vancouver itself, but I consider it to be my home – by birth and by choice. I accept the housing cost as the price to be paid for the benefits. It is what it is.
Being the “most beautiful” anything is not something one should continually brag about and take on as the core of one’s identity. If the most beautiful girl in the school were followed around the schoolyard by minions carrying placards saying “So-and-so is the most beautiful girl in the school,” and her family had bumper stickers, a sign in the front yard, a recording on the answering machine and regular newspaper ads, it would get tiresome very fast and would be incredibly arrogant. She certainly wouldn’t win the next popularity contest. We can have fun with that approach for a couple of weeks during the Miss School Beauty contest, but not forever! Similarly, I totally accept the practice of scholarship honours, sporting prizes, political campaigns, and best city declarations, but we need to keep a teensy bit of humility in the picture.
Why does Vancouver (and British Columbia) think it can go around telling everyone that it is more beautiful and a better place to live than their cities, and then expect to be loved universally? Other places are totally wonderful in their unique ways. Don’t get me wrong – I fully favour competition in school, sports and life. And winners should be declared, from time to time.
When our kids were young, the current philosophy seemed to be to make every child feel “special.” I declared on many occasions that I did NOT want my kids to think they were special. (Of course they were special to me – every kid should be special to their special people. Like cities, they are totally wonderful in their unique and sometimes private ways.) Children should learn that they are no more special to the world than anyone else. I am pleased – even proud, dare I say it – that they all grew up to be responsible people who expect to work for the things they want to enjoy, and nevertheless to accept that life
is not always fair.
So, if Vancouver leaders want to change city culture, they should start with humility as a necessary companion to pride. We have all the rest!
[Note: Ironic lack of humility in the last sentence was intended.]
9 thoughts on “Vancouver Stanley Cup 2011 riot, bandwagons, and humility”
This is very characteristic of people from Vancouver —- obsessively concerned about their city’s reputation. If sports fans riot in another city the people blame the rioters, the police, the mayor, the weather, alcohol, the parents of the rioters and whatever else they can. The principal concerns are the victims, the residents, the damaged businesses/real estate and how much the tax rates will go up to pay for the damage. How the city looks to outsiders is really a secondary concern of the residents.
The events were fairly predictable outcomes considering there were 100,000 drunken young people in the downtown core with not much to do at 7:00 at night — win or lose the game.
I am really really ticked by the national coverage of this —- as if Vancouver represented the entire country. The Stanley Cup which does represent the whole country has been forgotten completely despite the fact that the winning team has players from Bonavista NL to Vancouver, all of whom deserve some national news coverage.
I agree with most of what you say, but think that the national media were very keen to talk about Vancouver’s reputation. “100,000 drunken young people” does not quite represent the crowd, but I agree that the events should not have been a big surprise.
For example here is a lovely description of our local boy from Jackie MacMullan of ESPNBoston.com
The goalie was not the only one who rose to the occasion when the stage was at its grandest. Halifax’s own Brad Marchand, the rookie agitator whose imprint was all over this series, set up Patrice Bergeron for the first goal, then knocked in a wraparound goal from behind the net to make it 2-0 in the second period.
Marchand, who capped the scoring with an empty-netter, completed an electric postseason with 10 goals and eight assists. In games in which Marchand scored this postseason, the Bruins were 9-0.
“Call him a weasel, a rat, whatever you want,” Boston defenseman Dennis Seidenberg said. “He was the spark that got us going.”
Tonight the National still had an eleven minute lead story on the Vancouver riot aftermath — unending reality show. I really am flummoxed by this silly coverage of kissing couples, guilty water polo players. citizen heroes blah blah blah. I refuse to look at the video apology of the only person to be outed — talk about a scapegoat! I simply want the story to go away or at least recede to the regional level where I can find it when I want an update.
Hahaja. Tell us what you really think! At least I added an unrelated post to my blog to move this story off the top. However, I’m enjoying your comments.
“But Anton says officers on the street were under-resourced and everyone seemed to miss signs that the crowd of more than 100,000 drunken youths gathering on the streets was going to be more than a family affair.”
Being a political opponent of the mayor, she is probably not giving the most accurate report of the crowd composition, but I get your point: there were a lot of drunken youths, which is inviting trouble.
It even made top news here in Australia!
And what do you mean I have to work for the things I enjoy!? (..joking)
Pingback: Patio gardening in the third-most-liveable city in the world | Seeing Clarely
Comments are closed.